Skip to main content

Not wearing the ruby slippers...

This past week the tech world has been a-buzz about the new Facebook Home experience. For weeks we've been getting the pre-announcement rumblings... is Facebook launching a new app? A new phone? A bio-implant chip that records every thought you have as a new status update? Well, we finally got the answer, and thankfully they've decided not to enter the cybernetic implant realm... at least not yet.

Facebook's new experience is a set of apps for Android phones that transforms your UI into a fully Facebook experience. Your lock screen and home screen get transformed into slick versions of your Facebook news page, combined with your phone's email and messaging. Your messaging gets merged together with Facebook Messenger so that you can ping people on Facebook or SMS through the same app. And, photos from your feed become background images on your home and lock screens, so you can always see the latest drunken stupor your friends are in, without having to log into an app.

Facebook said in it's announcement that it wanted to make your phone about "people, not apps". I immediately thought to myself, "Didn't Microsoft just try this with Windows 8 and Live Tiles?" I wasn't the only one to think that either (Microsoft compares Facebook Home presentation to Windows Phone launch). But beyond the problem of trying to make a paradigm shift that others are already attempting, the biggest issue I see with this is that it depends so heavily on a single company for the entire experience.

Unlike other apps that try to change your phone experience to make it less app-centric, this attempt depends solely on your desire to make your world revolve around a single social networking provider. Unlike other attempts at social/phone integration, such as Microsoft Live Tiles, the original WebOS account sync, or even the iOS attempts at service integration, this one is tied to one service, and one service alone. Maybe that's fine, but it requires that you are willing to let Facebook be your almost-complete, one-stop shop.

This is where I think the fatal flaw is. The common refrain when talking about how Facebook makes money, is that on Facebook "YOU are the product." Because Facebook is free, it becomes a service not about what you want to partake in, but about what Facebook can use, that you give it, to sell to others. I'm not criticizing this model per se, simply stating the reality of the situation. So when you consider Facebook Home, it's not necessarily about giving you a better phone experience, it's about bringing you deeper into the world of being a product that companies pay Facebook to access.

Let's look at the photo background piece of Facebook Home for example. It shows you the latest photos on your News Feed that your friends have shared. Beyond the immense potential for abuse, and the general question of trusting your friends to not post garbage (Facebook Home is beautiful but what if your friends aren't), is the potential to end up having your phone be a billboard in our pocket. When I look over my friend feed in Facebook, I get a fair number of pics of people and their kids, but a large number of photos on my feed are products, or bands, or causes, that my friends have "Liked". So not, if my friend 'likes' a pic of the latest laptop from Lenovo, that pic has the chance of showing up on my Facebook Home screen, and as Mark Zuckerberg said, you stare at your home and lock screen a LOT every day.

There has been talk lately of young people starting to drift away from the "always-sharing" mentality of a few years ago. Although kids are still using social networking sites in record numbers, the trend seems to be changing ever so slightly. I don't believe that we'll ever get to a point where people give up on social networking sites, and in fact I think they are incredibly powerful ways to connect with people. But the need to have a social networking site be totally pervasive in our life experience, is a trend I'd hope to see continue to decline. So then the question becomes, do we need something like Facebook Home? I give them kudos for developing a nice and beautiful interface, but perhaps it's a hammer looking for a nail that might not exist.

In this particular case, I don't think I'll be clicking my heels anytime soon, wishing to go back over the rainbow and find my (Facebook) Home...

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

I love typing on my iPad

Ok, before you think I've gone crazy and suddenly believe I like smacking away at a non-responsive touch-screen, let me clarify that title... "I love typing on my bluetooth keyboard on my iPad." Like many people, I took the plunge and got a wireless keyboard for my iPad, because for any serious typing work, you really can't beat the smooth responsiveness of the Apple Wireless keyboard. But, just to clarify things further, it's not the bluetooth keyboard that is the reason I love typing on my iPad. Let's correct that title one more time... "I love writing on my bluetooth keyboard on my iPad." There we go, that's better, and it gets to the heart of what I wanted to share in this post. I'm going to make a bold statement, which I'm sure tons of people will find issue with, but here is it. The iPad is a perfect writing tool. Ya, that's right. I just said that a small 10 inch device that you need to purchase an additional keyboard for

I don't have a wood shop...

It's been a few weeks since my last entry on this site, and there's been a good reason. No, it's not because there hasn't been anything interesting to write about, I certainly didn't take advantage of many good opportunities to write about tech news. It has been for a simple, somewhat silly reason. The new Warcraft expansion launched. I hear the groans now, all the way through the ether. People screaming "Oh no... he's one of THEM!" Well, sorry to disappoint, but yes, I am "one of them". But, some clarification is in order. I don't abandon my family to play WoW, I get my work done, I don't call in sick, etc., etc.,. However, it does bring up an interesting new phenomenon in our modern society. Gaming as a hobby. It's long been a staple of adult life to fill our time with hobbies and pastimes that give us something to do beyond work, but yet challenge us a bit mentally or physically. Video gaming has been around only a few deca

My week with a Windows 8.1 tablet

A week or so ago I had an opportunity to purchase an inexpensive 8" tablet that ran a full version of Windows 8.1. So, being the adventurous sort, I headed out to the mall bright and early to get in line for a killer doorbuster deal. Although I didn't get the super-duper-amazing-low-price, I did manage to get the super-amazing-low-price, so I decided it was good enough to pick it up and try it out for a week to see what I thought about it. Who knows, I thought, it could even become me regular go-to tablet.  At first, I was planning to give it to my wife, but she decided she wanted to stick with her Nexus 7 (man that's a great tablet). So I started my experience, setting up my account the same way that you set up a regular Windows 8.1 desktop. In fact the process was completely 100% identical from the user experience, that is except for pushing buttons on a screen instead of a keyboard.  Once the account was set up, I started to explore how this thing works. Firs