Skip to main content

The Great Experiment

Recently, a tech journalist that I've followed for many years, and who is an Apple fanboy, posted a series talking about why he switched from an iPhone to an Android phone. It's a good read, and worth the time to see why he made the decision he did. Since I have a Verizon Galaxy Nexus sitting on my desk as a Wi-Fi device, I thought, "What the heck, let's give this a go for a week." So for the past week I've shelved my trusty iPhone 5 and have delved deep into the world of stock Android 4.1. So in the spirit of "copying is the sincerest form of flattery" here's my write-up of my experiences with Google's mobile OS.

First, I need to make one caveat. After using the Nexus for a week I have to say that I do NOT like this device. It constantly loses 4G signal, and the battery life almost makes it unusable. I could barely make it to lunch before I was at 20-30% battery. So in the spirit of fairness, if I truly wanted to switch full time to Android, I would have returned this one to the store and gotten something different. Ok, with that disclaimer out of the way, let's proceed.

Things I missed from iOS:

  • Badges on icons
    One of the things I really like about iOS is that I can visually see on an icon how many new items I need to look at (badges are those little numbers in the corner of an icon). I know other skins for Android provide a bit of this functionality, but the uniformity of iOS is really nice. Stock Android doesn't even have a badge on it's icons for number of new text messages. 
  • Robust proxy configuration
    My place of employment requires the use of a proxy server to get on our corporate wireless. However, the ability to selectively turn on a proxy for one wireless network, and off for others, is something that Android does not have out of the box. This is the first occasion where I ran in to the dreaded comment, "Well, you can root it do get that functionality." For my test experience this week my one stipulation was that I would not root the phone. I wanted to experience Android the way it was intended by the developers.
  • Battery life
    Again, this is dependent on the device, but on the Nexus, battery life was abysmal. One complaint about iOS is that Apple locks everything down so much, but for the sake of battery life, I think I can accept that trade off. Now, on other people's Android devices they get much better battery life, more akin to my iPhone 5. But, from my observation, even they still don't quite measure up. 
  • Lack of silence button
    Again, this is very device dependent, but for the most part a lot of Android devices don't have a nice quick physical switch to enter vibrate mode. I like the ability to simply reach in to my pocket, feel for the switch and flick it without ever having to pull my phone out. Personal preference, but it's something that I found annoying about the Nexus. 
  • Siri
    Although Google Now is a decent interface, for what I use Siri for it falls short. The most common thing I use Siri for is reading and dictating text messages. Having a physical button means I don't even have to look at my phone to start telling it what to do. I was able to get Google Now to act in a somewhat similar fashion, but it was always much more distracting than Siri.

Things like like better than iOS:

  • Choice of apps to use
    Why oh why can't I pick a different mail app? Or a different browser? Or a different X app for opening file types of Y? The fact that I was able to completely strip out the stock apps, and tell Android to use the apps of my choice was a refreshing change. That's a nice simple customization I wish I could have in iOS.
  • Customization of screens/Widgets
    I don't need to have all my apps on screens. I love the ability to make my home screen have just the apps I want, and then fill the rest with widgets. Being stuck with a grid of icons for my home screen is annoying and a relic of iOS 1.0, and I wish it would change. Major points for Android on this front.
  • Notifications
    Although iOS notifications have gotten better, I still think that Android has the upper hand here. The pull down menu, even in it's stock configuration, is clean, simple, and easy to clear out after you've scanned your new items. I know on various flavors of Android that the pull down menu is even more robust. Again, something I'd love to see more control of in iOS.
  • Quick settings controls
    Seems silly, but having the quick controls available as a widget is such a great idea. I hate having to hit multiple menus every time I want to turn on Bluetooth. Apple, PLEASE fix this!
  • Google integration
    Pretty obvious that this would be the case, but integration with the Google suite of apps is stellar on Android. Everything works, and works well. Plus the addition of apps like Google Talk makes Google the clear winner in this category.

Toss up:

  • App switching
    I put this one in the toss-up category because, although the iOS app switcher isn't as nice and easy to use as the Android one, it still functions almost the same way, and gives the same functionality. I'd still prefer Apple to come up with something better, but the iOS one is still quite nice.
  • Built-in apps
    Since it really depends if you're a Google user or not, I didn't pick a "winner" for the built-in apps. Plus, the fact that many Android phones come with pre-installed apps kinda stinks. For the most part though the built-in apps work well on both platforms.
  • General usability
    For the most part, I was able to use an Android phone just as easy as I was able to use my iPhone. Both have come a long way in improving usability to the general user, and both provide enough visual cues to help people figure things out without having to look up an answer.
  • Video chatting
    Both iOS and Android provide ways to video chat with others. However, for my iOS is superior because the people I video chat with are on iOS devices, meaning Facetime integration. The video chats in Google Talk on Android are fine, and work as advertised, so this one is really a toss up based on what service your family/friends are on.
So at the end of the week, I've now gone back to my iPhone 5. Although, I do so with the knowledge that with the right device, one that has much better battery life for example, I could live just fine in Android. This was a fun experiment to do, and it gave me reasons to really look at what I needed my phone to do, and what was just fluff. I will probably miss the larger screen a bit on the Nexus, and maybe someday Apple will go a bit wider, but for now my iPhone 5 does what I need it to do, and does it well. 


Popular posts from this blog

The beat goes on

Yesterday Apple revealed their long awaited entry into the streaming music field. They were able to do this quickly because of the acquisition of Beats last year, and the systems and intellectual property that came with that purchase. Considering that the music reveal was pretty much the only big news out of a pretty benign developer keynote, I'll take a few moments to talk about what I think about it.

Apple was perhaps the defining company in the music revolution of the past 20 years. With the introduction of the iPod that revolutionized portable music, to the creation of the iTunes store and the eventual death of DRM, Apple has been at the forefront of digital music. This leadership comes with high expectations to continue to lead, and so many people have long questioned Apple not getting into the streaming music business quicker.

For the past few years new companies have come forth to lead the change in the streaming music evolution. From Pandora and its ability to create uniqu…

Push it... push it real good...

The other day I got a chance to play with the new Apple force touch trackpad. This is a new design that Apple has put on their laptops for non-mechanized clicking on trackpad. When you press on the trackpad it senses the force that you're pressing with, and when you reach a certain level, you feel a 'click'. If you keep pressing, you feel a second 'click'. The unique thing is that these 'clicks' aren't physical in nature. The trackpad never moves at all, but the click that you feel is from haptic feedback. In essence, when you press with enough force, the trackpad clicks back at you. You feel the sensation of clicking, but it's simply the trackpad responding to your pressure.

I got to play with this for a while, since the Apple Store rep was talking with us about soccer, and after a short bit I was getting the hang of it. I feel that it would take quite a bit longer though to really feel comfortable with this new paradigm. I'm someone who has a …

Oh Instant Messaging, I hardly knew you

For many years, I've been a big fan of Instant Messaging as a way to communicate with friends, especially those in other parts of the country. Sure e-mail works, but if you want to have a conversation with someone immediately, with a lot of back and forth, IM was the way to go. I jumped on the IM bandwagon all the way back in the ICQ days (and no, I don't remember my number). Followed by a bunch of years maintaining multiple protocols at the 'Big 3' at the time; AOL Instant Messaging (AIM), MSN Messenger and Yahoo Messenger. Many of us recall the years of running three different clients on our desktop at all times, because all of our friends used different systems. Thankfully, it wasn't too long before multi-protocol clients came into play and we could start to consolidate.

Google was a late comer to the market, but it's GTalk Instant Messenger caught on fast. It was slim and trim and since GMail was the rage, everyone had a log-in. Slowly, over the course of 5…